Natsuiro Kiseki


Okay, so let me try this–I’m not really a big Sphere fan; I enjoy the works of the voice actresses on their own, and some of their singles are pretty fun to listen to. I also have a couple of their albums. But somehow I have these conceptions, perhaps true, perhaps not.

Ayahi is the least popular. I think it’s unfortunate that given a group of real-life idols you’re going to have a person with more fans than others, but that’s just how it is. It’s not even for the fact that she might be the most talented out of the group, as people generally recognize that Ayahime probably has the best singing voice out of the four.

Minako is the prettiest, at least by recognition. But she is probably the least capable actress in the group.

Aki and Haruka are the most prolific, but obviously Aki is the most popular and Haruka, aside from being boosted by her solo stints pre-Sphere, is a little more of a controversial idol. At any rate the two of them just have done more, be it singing or voice acting; I believe a lot of the times they land roles simply because of their relatively diverse skills and in Haruka’s case, a great range of voices she can do.

I don’t think he’s too off base to say that Saki has a major part in the show and she might be the “best” character. I also don’t think it’s a coincidence that Minako and Ayahi have a lot of lines; in a way this anime is made to showcase the girls in Sphere, especially those who do not get lead roles so often. I also think the four characters, in some way, match their voice actors in terms of their perceived personalities.

What you get in return, though, is that Minako just doesn’t quite cut it. I thought it was tolerable but the scene on the boat during the episode when Natsumi confronts Saki about Saki’s feelings really tested Minako’s ability to do a convincing job. I thought she passed; given Yuka is probably one of the most phoned-in role from Tomatsu in recent memory, it doesn’t behoove to be overly strict about Sphere voice acting in the Sphere anime when the characters are simply takes on the girls themselves.

Indeed, what do you have left? Aki’s Rinko is adorable, but given how little she speaks and that the passing bar is “adorable” it is a shoo-in for Aki. Ayahi’s Saki, again, carries the torch. I thought the Yuka-as-Saki episode is one of the most interesting thing I’ve seen in a long while, at least from the voice acting perspective. I suppose in the end there’s still something to be said of hearing Minako as a straight-and-narrow tomboy, which just never really happens.

As for the story and production value and music and whatever, well, I have no complaints. The writing saved this show. Seiji Mizushima has solid chops. I have liked Nijine’s sound in the past and Masumi Ito’s involvement probably helps a bit. The animation was tough and rough at times but they doubled down when it counted. The theme and the plot devices works to both obfuscate the basic premise and add a predictable but comfortable depth to the characterization that subtleness├é┬áhas room to grow. Like the hug Yuka gave Natsumi at the end.

Let me unpack that a bit. The character chemistry pairs off clearly from the start; it’s Yuka and Rinko, Natsumi and Saki. But there are a few precious moments like when Rinko flashes her flushed smile at Natsumi, or how Yuka’s own sense of joy about life infects Saki. It’s a bit like Rinko’s mom, knowingly squint at Natsumi’s mom in the last episode.

I thought that was probably the climax of the series right about there. Except that was probably a few weeks ago when they visited Saki’s new home-to-be.

4 Responses to “Natsuiro Kiseki”

  • Fencedude

    Symphogear really raised my awareness of Takagaki Ayahi. She was always one of the seiyuu who was “around” doing lots of roles but never really made it into my consciousness as someone I should pay more attention to. After Symphogear started and she showed up, I looked more into her and was shocked at how many characters that I really like she had done.

    As you say about Natsumi and Saki, Natsumi was the “main” character, but the show was about Saki. To a minor extent. If the story were a little different, Natsumi’s spot would have been filled by the male lead. As it is, there are a limited number of things that could end that sentence Natsumi started on the boat, and its a real shame the show never went there.

    As for the acting, I don’t know if I entirely agree with you, especially about Kotobuki Minako. I generally find her to be a delightful actress, and Natsumi may not have been her best role ever, but it was certainly different. She’s got quite a bit of range, if not so much as Tomatsu (who was very generically Tomatsu as Yuka, but it worked). Takagaki and Toyosaki were as you mentioned.

    • omo

      I think Ayahi really took on stage for me via Mitsudomoe. I mean I was aware of her after True Tears and more so as Sphere took off, but I really enjoyed her in that.

      On the other hand I just haven’t been impressed by Minako, as a rule.

  • Chad

    It really is a shame that Ayahi is not as popular as the other three girls in the group. This is especially frustrating because people generally agree that she has the best singing voice of the group.

  • Chad

    What did you think of her in Symphogear by the way?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.