The Other 2.5D, Scarlet Rain

You know how there’s a furry scale? There’s probably something like a mecha scale too.

No, not really about Strike Witches (even if that’s a good example of both types of scales). Actually, one of the more attractive aspect of mechanical design for popular media is its ability to transform. A big reason people like the F-14 is its moving-sweeping wings. It is not a surprise to see the now-retired assault aircraft pairing off with futuristic valks in Macross Zero. And as you know, these witches transform into furry beings by magic and military weapons by mechanical parts.

The value in transformation almost implicitly point out that the degree of mechanization for a mechamusume is not a quantized value, but a sliding scale. It’s one thing to paint a girl’s picture to the side of your aircraft or bomb or tank. It’s another to replace the giant robot and replace it with a girl-android-thing. Maybe we can even put, at the extreme ends, just girls piloting these things on one side, and girls piloting these other things on the other end of the scale.

You know Aegis from Persona 3? She’s a pretty much middle-of-the-road for mechamusume. Now by definition mechamusume is combing traditional mecha with that moe bishoujo aesthetics, like “girl+tank” or “girl+RX-78“. Aegis is just a straight-up android, and by definition human-like robots will exhabit some humanlike-ness. If that style of¬†femininity is what the android has, it might be difficult to consider that as mechamusume. Perhaps as a new dimensionality?

But to a degree one end of the mechamusume spectrum is kind of like how people get off on guro or, say, ableist porn–it’s all normal except insert-the-blank, where the blank is some kind of abnormal physiology. Androids approach this idea from the opposite, in that the question is how human-like that they may be, except for their ears and the on-off switch, as an example. I would say these kinds of mechamusume are almost just normal people; that’s kind of their schtik. That’s the 0%. After all we don’t quite put Miku in this category.

I think Scarlet Rain is a pretty good example of both the more extreme form of mechamusume, as well as the idea of this non-fixed value of how much of a mechamusume a character could be. For one, in Accel World, you are your avatar, and it isn’t something you pilot exactly–you could kind of control it, but it is ultimately presented as the version of you in Accel World. So in that sense, when Scarlet Rain is doing her bit of the story inside the Accel World universe, she’s only known as Scarlet Rain, and not Yuniko. It’s a pretty serious transformation in contrast with Strike Witches, don’t you think?

Or maybe better yet, perhaps we can posit that it is Strike Witches that is progressive in combining the mechanical aspect of the girls with the innate identities thereof. Yuniko is still just Yuniko in the real world, after all. To the degree Power Ranger Pink can transform from mundane to magical (sometimes with the hardware), it speaks a lot about the place our characters inhibit within the scope of what makes of mechamusume. As I would put it, it’s about venturing into that 2.5D land, that gap between the common-sensical and the fantastically two-dimensional construct of the mechamusume.

I suppose Drossel has met her match, though. Long live the (tsundere imouto) Red King!

[I wrote this before Summer Wanfest 2012, so for reference check out this and that. Or this plamo KOS-MOS, the most moe weapons platform]


7 Responses to “The Other 2.5D, Scarlet Rain”

  • DiGiKerot

    Yeah, I want that Scarlet Rain figma also.

  • Fencedude

    I rather shamlessly adore mecha-musume, and I basically agree with what you have here.

    On a side note, considering Accel World’s conceit about avatars, what does it say about Yuniko that her avatar essentially herself, only metal?

  • vendredi

    I can’t help but feel there’s a database spectrum to these sorts of things too, kind of a “how much of the original weapon/vehicle/aircraft is represented via some metaphor”. Strike Witches works on multiple levels for this too; representing not just aircraft but historical persons.

    And then there’s oddball things like Muv-Luv, where the ‘mecha are essentially the same as today’s planes: it’s just that whatever parallel timeline we’re in they happened to be developed into giant robots instead but still followed the same overall development trajectory (and involved the same historical people).

    It’s rather surprising how, well, deep into military trivia a lot of Japanese products are, despite having a military that’s essentially hamstrung by their Constitution (or perhaps that’s a cause of it?)

    • Fencedude

      See also Upotte! and Gun Culture in Japan. Same deal.

    • omo

      Just as a point of clarification, these shows target the otaku, not the mainstream. They want military trivia, so there they are. I think it’s amusing how the trivia soaks into the stories in the meta as a way to entertain. But it also makes you wonder if there’s more to it.

Leave a Reply to Fencedude Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.